Having driven the Alfa Romeo at breakneck speed along the Autostrada from Rome right up the middle of the boot, we arrived in Rieti , Italy , just across the hill from Montepulciano d’Abruzzo (a fact which becomes quite important later). I had to go at breakneck speed because (a) I was falling asleep due to excessive jet lag and (b) it was not possible to pass anyone on the two lane highway except by driving on the shoulder, or pushing the other guy onto the shoulder so you could pass.
Napping intermittently, we pulled into the city (founded by the Romans, and still sporting a huge wall), and were claustrophobically funneled through streets exactly three inches wider than the car itself, before being vomited out into an expansive square in front of our hotel. There the car sat for the next three days, mainly because it was more sane, and more fun, to walk everywhere.
Being in the heart of Italy , I wanted to eat Italian made by Italians for Italians. Stupidly, we asked the concierge at the hotel where we could go to get such a meal. “Why, the best restaurant in all Rieti happened to be just around the corner”, he said, with a gleam in his eye that later proved to be caused by the kickback he obviously received from the owner of said “restaurant”, for sending gullible tourists from North America there. Let’s just say the pasta almost ascended to the culinary accomplishment of Italian master chef Boy-Ar-Dee, with the pizza coming just short of Little Caesar’s.
This left me pretty disheartened. I was, obviously, in Rieti to attend an important conference on prevention of biological, chemical and nuclear threats, but secretly, as ever, I was also there to eat.
The next night, my two American and one British colleague and I set off on foot, expertly ducking into doorways at just the right moment to avoid losing a limb to a passing Fiat or Vespa, and eventually finding ourselves stopping in front of “Tito” in garish blue neon. Being from a land in which bright neon usually advertises American beer and French fries with gravy, we weren’t entirely convinced – but the door opened, releasing a cloud of fragrance so complex and delicious it made my knees buckle. The quick glimpse inside revealed a place packed to the gills with loud, laughing and obviously extremely satisfied people.
We went in. A blond man with Mahatma Gandhi glasses, but obviously Etruscan and therefore utterly belonging there, strode up to me confidently, and parked his face three inches from mine, as is the custom in all Latin-influenced places. He didn’t have to say a word – before I knew what I was saying, I knew this place was his, and therefore I could brazenly tell him that we were travelers here for but three days, that we were not interested in the menu, but that instead, we just wanted him to please prepare for us whatever would show off the heart and soul of this beautiful region of Italy.
His eyes filled briefly with the kind of gratitude that happens only when you happen to say exactly the thing that someone has been yearning to hear all his life. I just got lucky, I guess – and boy, were we about to find out just how lucky. As he pulled out my chair, I risked another question – were the black truffles by any chance in season right now? (I had never had truffles of any description, and it was about bloody time, being that the guidebooks were confident that Rieti is a hotbed of truffledom in Italy ). His disappointment was palpable – “No, the truffles are just out of season, but there is another mushroom now coming into its own….ah, I will show you something, please do not worry”.
One of our group, whom I will call Sarjit, (because that is his name), briefly fingered the menu on the table. He was not entirely sure that throwing ourselves on the mercy of the chef was all that safe an idea…I couldn’t blame him, being that he had been expertly relieved of his laptop by a couple of suave and erudite pickpockets on the train that morning. No wonder he was jittery. He asked Tito if he could perhaps have the sautéed prawns instead of whatever other appetizer was coming. Tito was gracious.
The prawns appeared, in full unpeeled glory, heads and antennae still intact. Sarjit took one look, and announced to me that he had ‘just remembered’ that he was in fact ‘allergic to shellfish’. It only took me a second to wonder how someone forgot such a thing before I graciously volunteered to eat his shellfish for him. They were sautéed in brandy, and utterly, stupendously sublime.
Our appetizer arrived. It was scrambled eggs on fresh bread – garnished with black truffles. I took a bite. Tito hovered nearby. Time stopped. Never, ever have I had anything so intensely, astonishingly powerful in my mouth. I cannot describe this without becoming exceedingly graphic and intimate – and now I know why people willingly shell out hundreds, if not thousands of dollars for mere shavings of this earthy, sensual, compulsive ecstasy of taste.
Tito smiled knowingly, and disappeared.
Pasta is the next course in Italy – served before the meat course. Our pasta came with peas and sweetbreads – thymus glands of a calf – (which is why they are called sweetbreads, because merely saying ‘thymus’ tends to put off one’s appetite). These came in a white wine cream sauce, in a portion expertly sized to make one want more meat.
Osso buco obligingly followed. Braised veal shanks, to be specific. This dish made the trip to America with the first flood of Italian immigrants, so therefore its very familiarity might make one pause and wonder if traveling to Italy to experience it might just be a letdown. No fear of that. These calves’ calves had obviously never needed to climb any of Rieti’s pitched pastures or cobbled streets. Coddled for hours in a red wine sauce, the veal practically slid off the bone, and gave up in a meltingly rich burst of meaty essence in the mouth. Tito served a red Montepulciano d’Abruzzo wine, with no label. I cavalierly asked him where I might get such a bottle to take back home with me. “No”, he said, shaking an emphatic finger. “We don’t send this to your country. This we keep for ourselves….”
Dessert was vanilla gelato, flooded with espresso made tableside. A perfect balance of deeply rounded bitterness with exquisitely sweet and creamy vanilla.
The second dessert – because Tito, with eyes shining, told us that he had rarely seen anyone enjoy food so much – was on the house. A platter of plain, white cookies, each unadorned except for a single hazelnut, arrived. Tito stopped us from grabbing one, patiently pouring the Vin Santo and explaining that the Italian way was to dip the cookie – like so – into the sweet wine before eating.
We dipped, and ate, and pondered again our very, very good luck.
Then came the bill. It was my turn, since those around the table represented two companies working together now for many years. We just took turns picking up the tab. My palms were a bit sweaty, thinking how I was going to explain this to accounting, and honestly thinking this meal might be worth being fired over.
Sixty dollars (US). Total. For four people.
The next night – our last in that city – I tried to convince the group that we needed to return to Tito Di Brucchietti Dario. I lost. They said there was no way that meal could ever be equaled. I beg to differ. The reason that place has been in that family for over a century is precisely because they CAN equal that meal, day after day. I’m going back there, someday.